Science for Policy
86 episodes - English - Latest episode: 4 months ago -How far should we rely on science to make political decisions? What makes a good science advisor — or a good science advice system? What do we do when the evidence is incomplete or controversial? What happens when science advice goes wrong and how can we fix it? We explore these questions, and many more, in conversation with the researchers, policymakers and communicators who make science advice happen around the world.
The Science for Policy podcast is produced the Scientific Advice Mechanism to the European Commission and hosted by Toby Wardman. The many and varied opinions expressed on this podcast are those of the guests themselves. They do not necessarily represent the views of SAPEA or the European Commission.
Homepage Apple Podcasts Google Podcasts Overcast Castro Pocket Casts RSS feed
Episodes
Bart van den Hurk and Jana Sillmann on storytelling
January 02, 2024 05:45 - 47 minutes - 75.3 MBIn a scientific field as complex and multifaceted as climate modelling, how do you communicate the realities of concrete impacts to stakeholders and policymakers? Two IPCC scientists, Bart van den Hurk and Jana Sillmann, are working on so-called 'storylines' techniques, which generate high-resolution, interdisciplinary stories to help decision-makers in all fields assess their own readiness for climate-related changes. Resources mentioned in this episode https://climatestorylines.eu/
Moniek Tromp on youth and diversity in science advice
December 11, 2023 05:45 - 45 minutes - 73.5 MBHow diverse are the people who work on scientific advice -- and why does this matter? Should we be involving more young people as experts, and are there any trade-offs in doing so? What impact might changes in academic culture more broadly have on the quality and availability of evidence for policy? Professor Moniek Tromp, a founding member of the Young Academies Science Advice Structure and a member of the COARA coalition on improving research assessment, reflects on what's working well an...
Tome Sandevski and Michèle Knodt on informal science-policy fellowships
November 13, 2023 05:30 - 28 minutes - 50 MBBeyond the world of institutional design and formalised competences that tend to be the focus of science-for-policy scholarship, there are many less structured interfaces between the worlds of research and policymaking. One such well-established interface is the Mercator science-policy fellowship, run by three German universities and headed by Tome Sandevski. In this episode, Toby Wardman of the SAM talks to Tome and his colleague Michèle Knodt, who is currently taking part in the scheme.
Tim Marler & Sana Zakaria on gene editing and AI policy
October 30, 2023 05:30 - 51 minutes - 81.1 MBDrawing on their broad portfolio of exciting, sci-fi-sounding research areas, Tim Marler and Sana Zakaria from RAND Corporation talk in depth about how the latest scientific evidence on AI and gene-editing can best be communicated to policymakers nationally and globally. What are the hot topics? What decisions do policymakers face right now? Where can different kinds of scientific evidence help to inform those decisions, and where are policymakers on their own? Resources mentioned in this e...
Glenn Fernandez on municipal science advice in the Philippines
October 16, 2023 04:45 - 22 minutes - 40.8 MBThe Philippines is remarkably exposed to natural disasters, from earthquakes to typhoons to volcanic eruptions. Dr Glenn Fernandez, a disaster risk management expert, started his science advice career as a masters student and has continued ever since, helping cities and rural municipalities to prepare for and respond to emergencies. In this episode, he shares his experiences and insights with Toby Wardman from the SAM.
Veera Mitzner on events as science-for-policy activities
October 02, 2023 04:34 - 26 minutes - 46.1 MBVeera Mitzner is the organiser of the Sustainability Research and Innovation Congress, a major annual event which brings together thousands of researchers, stakeholders and, yes, policymakers. But how do events like this fit into the broader evidence-for-policy landscape?
Stella Ladi on science advice in Greece
September 18, 2023 04:46 - 28 minutes - 49.2 MBGreece does not have a long tradition of institutionalised science advisory mechanisms, but after dealing relatively well with Covid, the situation is starting to change. Professor Stella Ladi, an expert on evidence-informed policymaking at home and internationally, talks to Toby Wardman about the past, present and future of science advice in Greece. Professor Ladi has been promoted since this conversation was recorded! Hence she is referred to as 'Dr Ladi' at the start of the episode.
Ottmar Edenhofer on giving climate advice in Europe
September 04, 2023 04:30 - 32 minutes - 54.6 MBThe EU climate law created a new institution, the European Scientific Advisory Board on Climate Change, which started work just this year and targets the European Commission, Parliament and Council. Its chair, Professor Ottmar Edenhofer, took time out of his busy schedule to share with us what it's like setting up a new science advice body and how happy he is with their first significant report. Resources mentioned in this episode https://climate-advisory-board.europa.eu/
Hugh Pope on experts in sortition-based democracies
August 21, 2023 04:45 - 39 minutes - 64.7 MBElections are not the only way to power democratic decision-making. A system of government by random selection of citizens, or 'sortition', has been around since at least ancient Athens and, as Hugh Pope explains, has never quite disappeared. But if we adopt such a radically different way of making policy, what are the implications of science for policy? Do experts take on different roles, and how can citizen-politicians acquire the skills they need to make judgement calls on scientifically...
Marc Sanjaume i Calvet on scientific expertise in conflict resolution
August 07, 2023 04:45 - 50 minutes - 79.6 MBWhat do science advisors have to offer in conflict situations? Can evidence and expertise ever cut through political polarisation and contribute to finding new forms of compromise? What kinds of advisors do we need, and what kinds of advice? Should they be strictly neutral, or is plurality and openness more useful? Do politicians really want scientific evidence, and what if it puts pressure on their longstanding political positions? Our guest today, Marc Sanjaume i Calvet, is an expert on t...
Ole Øvretveit & Eystein Jansen on Ukraine, the Arctic and the climate crisis
July 17, 2023 04:45 - 52 minutes - 71.9 MBWelcome to the Arctic, where science-for-policy and policy-for-science collide in increasingly complicated ways. You can't make climate-change policy anywhere in the world without scientific evidence we get from the Arctic — but at the same time, being able to get that evidence depends on a delicate balance of policies and geopolitical interests that have made collaborative research between Europe, North America and Russia possible since before the Cold War. But then you might have heard th...
Eleni Zika on curiosity-driven research and its contribution to policy
July 03, 2023 04:30 - 35 minutes - 58.3 MBMost of Europe's colossal Horizon research funding programme is laser-focused on strategic objectives set by policymakers. But one Horizon-funded institution, the European Research Council, breaks the mould: its grants are awarded on the basis of excellence alone, and as Dr Eleni Zika explains, they are proud to deliberately ignore questions such as the usefulness of science to policy or society. Why, then, has the ERC recently set up its own 'feedback to policy' unit, which would seem to g...
Barbara Vis on heuristics
June 19, 2023 04:30 - 46 minutes - 73 MBPoliticians are humans, and humans do not always reason syllogistically from premises to conclusions. The problem is amplified when political decisions have to be made fast, under conditions of uncertainty, with either not enough information or far too much. That's where heuristics come in -- and Professor Barbara Vis is here to help us understand when they are used, what their impacts can be, and how we should take that into account when delivering science advice.
Heather Rogers & Jelka Zaletel on implementation science
June 05, 2023 04:45 - 51 minutes - 80.1 MBWhen Slovenia rolled out its national diabetes plan, they had the evidence, they had the funding, they had the centres, they had the doctors and nurses... but people didn't show up. Simply having the right information is not enough to build an effective policy. You can't just factor out the complexities — you need to factor them in. Heather Rogers and Jelka Zaletel tell us more about the intriguing topic of implementation science. Podcast community Join our listener community, meet other...
Salvatore Aricò on science advice at the United Nations
May 22, 2023 04:43 - 46 minutes - 72.3 MBHow might the future of science advice look at the global level? Will the establishment of a UN Group of Friends on Science for Action be the catalyst that elevates science advice to the highest levels of multilateral decision-making, and how will this complement the Secretary-General's renewed scientific advisory board? And what should the role of the international science community be? In this episode, Dr Salvatore Aricò, chief executive of the International Science Council, shares his ex...
Frans Brom on strategic science advice in the Netherlands
May 08, 2023 04:30 - 42 minutes - 67.1 MBThe Netherlands Scientific Council for Government Policy is the cherry on top of an intricate and diverse ecosystem that provides for the science and evidence needs of policymakers in the Netherlands. It has a unique mandate: to look beyond the daily cut and thrust of politics, to challenge both government and parliament to think about important strategic issues that stretch into the future. Oh, and it reports directly to the prime minister. Too good to be true? You might well think so. But...
Bárbara Willaarts and Thomas Schinko on transdisciplinary research for policy
April 24, 2023 04:32 - 50 minutes - 78.9 MBIn this episode, Bárbara Willaarts and Thomas Schinko from the International Institute for Applied Systems Analysis explain why transdisciplinarity means more than just collaborating with other areas of science, and why co-creation means more than just working with policymakers to understand their needs... and why both are needed to give really good quality policy advice.
Please wear a mask
April 10, 2023 04:30 - 35 minutes - 57.1 MBIn this bonus episode shared from the limited-run podcast The Trust Race, Shane Bergin discusses public and political trust in science, using the advice on mask-wearing during the Covid-19 pandemic as an example. To listen to other episodes from The Trust Race, visit https://open.spotify.com/show/6jQ59Bxy7vGRecSzinxuaj. 'The Trust Race' has received funding from the EU’s Horizon 2020 research and innovation programme under grant agreement No 870883. The information and opinions are those o...
John O’Connor on education policy evidence in Ireland
March 27, 2023 11:40 - 54 minutes - 84.3 MBEducation is an interesting case study for the science-policy interface. It combines a complex, multi-stakeholder ecosystem, a range of different academic approaches, and very high political salience. Maybe that's why John O'Connor, a senior policymaker in the Qualifications and Quality Assurance Authority of Ireland, made it the subject of his PhD. He's here to tell us what makes science advice effective in education — and what makes it fail. With a bonus whirlwind tour of the entire scien...
The Mystery 100th Guest Episode Wooo
March 13, 2023 04:42 - 52 minutes - 80.6 MBNinety-nine brave adventurers have gone before. Who shall have the privilege of being the one hundredth guest on the Science for Policy podcast? And will they survive the ordeal? Join our brand new podcast community -- discuss what you've heard, ask questions to guests and and meet fellow listeners! Sign up here: https://join.slack.com/t/scienceforpol-iju8175/shared_invite/zt-1q94fmb6r-oG3q8QKf8cxXnKMNCkR77A
Jan-Pieter Krahnen on financial policy advice
February 27, 2023 05:45 - 42 minutes - 67.1 MBIs financial advice science advice? How independent can a financial advisor be? Did the world of economic policy advisors have their epiphany in 2008 in the same way that other sciences did in 2020? If anyone can answer these questions, it's Professor Jan-Pieter Krahnen!
Eleanor MacKillop & James Downe on knowledge brokering organisations
February 13, 2023 05:45 - 52 minutes - 81.3 MBIn a complex science-for-policy ecosystem, what role is filled by the so-called 'knowledge-brokering organisation'? It's not a scientific organisation, nor a science advisor, nor a think-tank, nor a policymaker. Yet these organisations abound and they can be highly influential — as Professor James Downe and Dr Eleanor MacKillop argue. In this episode, these two experts on this under-appreciated corner of the policymaking world explain to Toby Wardman the roles, challenges and strategies tha...
Carina Keskitalo on undead models of science advice
January 30, 2023 05:45 - 31 minutes - 52.3 MBWhat's that misshapen, lumbering form looming from the shadows? Why, it's the old linear model of science advice, already killed a thousand times over, but somehow still living -- and it's coming for YOU. Luckily, we have Professor Carina Keskitalo to hammer (another) stake into the heart of this monstrosity, with a tour-de-force about why you can't just tell your social scientists to shut up and do stakeholder engagement. Shoulder your crossbow, clutch your crucifix and enjoy! Resources ...
Christiane Gerblinger on how experts self-sabotage
January 16, 2023 05:45 - 31 minutes - 51.4 MBWhen science advisors are employed by governments, how do they reconcile the competing needs to accurately convey the science, while ensuring it can be of maximum use in the current political context? Dr Christiane Gerblinger has one answer: her research suggests that advisors adopt strategies to make themselves deliberately ignorable. Resources mentioned in this episode How Government Experts Self-Sabotage: The language of the rebuffed. https://press.anu.edu.au/publications/how-govern...
Noam Obermeister on how science advisors learn
December 19, 2022 05:45 - 43 minutes - 67.7 MBSo you want to be a science advisor? The bad news: there aren't really any books, powerpoint presentations or training courses that can teach you the skills you need. The good news: doctoral researcher Noam Obermeister has found out everything he can about the learning journeys of scientists who work with policymakers, both what they learn and how. And he might even be able to tell you if you will sink or swim. Resources mentioned in this episode Twitter thread on science advisors' lear...
Geoff Mulgan on how to synthesise knowledge
December 05, 2022 05:45 - 41 minutes - 65.3 MBOn this podcast, and in the world of science advice studies generally, we spend a lot of time discussing the science-policy interface and what should exist on the 'science' side of it in order to most effectively support policymaking. But Professor Sir Geoff Mulgan asks a different question: what happens on the other side of the interface, when policymakers are landed with a vast array of knowledge, theory and opinion, and have to somehow construct from that — and their own political and eco...
Barbara Prainsack on ethics advice in a crisis
November 21, 2022 05:45 - 44 minutes - 68.9 MBWe live in an age of crisis — and the crises that we face are more numerous, more widespread and more overlapping than ever before. In the chaos of high-pressure, life-and-death policymaking, politicians could benefit not just from scientific advice but also from the input of ethicists. That's where Barbara Prainsack, chair of the European Group on Ethics and New Technologies, comes into the picture. Resources mentioned in this episode Statement on values in times of crisis: https://res...
Rebecca Natow on politically-infused evidence use
November 07, 2022 05:45 - 37 minutes - 59.7 MBEvidence is not the exclusive province of science advisors and science advice institutions. And especially in policy areas where those institutions are weak or absent, other forces rush to fill the vacuum: stakeholders, lobbyists, interest groups. In this epsiode, Dr Rebecca Natow talks to Toby Wardman about federal education policy in the US, a domain that employs a 'negotiated rulemaking' methodology to try to find consensus among many stakeholders — even though scientific input is also l...
Jaishree Subrahmaniam and Marija Mitic on Marie Skłodowska-Curie Actions
October 24, 2022 04:45 - 37 minutes - 58.4 MBMarie Skłowdowska-Curie Fellowships, administered by the European Union, are some of the world's most prestigious academic fellowships, supporting researchers from all disciplines and at all stages of their careers. But alongside the core programmes are a growing number of activities designed to help researchers to interact with policymakers, from both the MSCA programme and the Alumni Association that has grown up around it. In this episode, Marija Mitic and Jaishree Subrahmaniam discuss t...
Chloe Hill on not looking up
October 10, 2022 04:45 - 36 minutes - 57.2 MBWhen a giant comet is hurtling towards Earth... when US president Orlean is more concerned about her approval ratings than preventing the extermination of all life... when the policy advice of America's greatest scientific minds is falling on deaf ears... when there is panic on the streets and the world's best response is capitalist greed... Who you gonna call? The world may be 99.7% doomed, but at least we have Chloe Hill on the line to point out what went wrong and how the science advis...
Rémi Quirion on the languages of global science advice
September 26, 2022 04:45 - 33 minutes - 53.9 MBThe emergence of English as the dominant international language of science has some significant downsides. One is the impact this has on science advice, where non-English-speaking countries risk finding themselves behind the curve in terms of both scholarship and practical applications. As part of his presidency of the International Network for Governmental Science Advice, Professor Rémi Quirion of Québec has made it his mission to broaden our linguistic outlook. In this joint episode co-pu...
Janusz Bujnicki on developing science advice in Poland
September 12, 2022 04:45 - 41 minutes - 63.8 MBFrom Brussels to Warsaw, Professor Janusz Bujnicki is helping to shape the future of scientific advice. In this episode, he compares his experiences advising the European Commission with current efforts to develop more high-level science advice mechanisms in his home country of Poland. With Toby Wardman of SAPEA, he discusses the value of transparency versus discretion, the distinction between policy-for-science and science-for-policy, and how to make mistakes gracefully as part of the learn...
Mark Ferguson on Solly Zuckerman
August 29, 2022 04:45 - 52 minutes - 79.7 MBSolly Zuckerman was the first chief scientific advisor to the UK government, a post he himself defined, and arguably one of the first to hold such a post in the world. His views, experiences and anecdotes from both the Second World War and the Cold War -- as described in a thousand or so pages of autobiography -- are so valuable that Mark Ferguson, today's guest, wishes he'd read them before he became chief scientific advisor to the Irish government. Don't make the same mistake as Mark and ...
Michael Bang Petersen on integrating psychology into policymaking
August 15, 2022 04:45 - 33 minutes - 52.4 MBPoliticians don't really have a great understanding of the citizens they serve, according to Michael Bang Petersen. In place of evidence from decades of psychological research, they tend to substitute their own instincts and common sense, together with more or less apposite fragments of behavioural science and economics. Nowhere was this more evident than during the early days of the Covid-19 pandemic, when opportunities to build trust and communicate science were squandered. Tune in and set...
Lieve Van Woensel on foresight
August 01, 2022 04:45 - 41 minutes - 63.5 MBForesight methodology helps science advisors check their blindspots, recognise their biases, and figure out the second- and third-order ripple effects of even the most innocuous of policy interventions. And Dr Lieve Van Woensel of the European Parliament, who talks to SAPEA's Toby Wardman in this episode, quite literally wrote the book on foresight. Resources mentioned in this episode A bias radar for responsible policymaking, by Lieve Van Woensel. https://lievevanwoensel.com/ European...
Scott Bremer on supply, demand and integrated science advice
July 18, 2022 04:45 - 56 minutes - 84.1 MBIn a very wide-ranging discussion, Dr Scott Bremer brings Toby Wardman up to speed on topics such as the inadequacy of the supply/demand dichotomy, the challenges of fitting the square peg of science into the round holes of real-world policy decisions, the relationship between scientific knowledge and other forms of knowing, and why he moonlights as a gardening therapist by the Norwegian fjords. Resources mentioned in this episode Sarewitz, D. (2004). How science makes environmental contro...
Peter Jackson and Marta Rivera Ferre on social sciences and framing
July 04, 2022 04:45 - 34 minutes - 53.6 MBWhile the natural sciences try to quantify and describe the natural world, the role of the social sciences is to understand people — including their many different attitudes, values and worldviews. This perspective is complex, but it is vital for policymakers, since policy directly engages with people. And, as Professors Peter Jackson and Marta Rivera Ferre argue, the way you frame a question can lead to radically different answers — even though different framings are equally valid. How does...
Lene Topp and Florian Schwendinger on competences for policymaking and advice
June 20, 2022 04:45 - 33 minutes - 51.8 MBWe know that being a science advisor for policymaking requires a set of skills, knowledge and attitudes that are often very different from those that come with being a researcher. And the same is true for policymakers, who also need to adopt new ways of working and thinking to integrate the evidence base into their work. Wouldn't it be nice if some kindhearted individuals took it upon themselves to comb through the literature to identify, list and organise all these essential competences, an...
Rebecca Fitzgerald and Harry De Koning on cancer screening policy
June 06, 2022 04:45 - 40 minutes - 61 MBNowhere is the tension between society-wide policy and individual choice as stark as in the field of public health. Can a committee of experts, informed by scientific evidence and in consultation with stakeholders, realistically make health decisions for a whole population? How might those decisions compare to the choices of individual patients and their physicians? Fresh from their work collecting evidence to inform screening programmes in the EU, Professors Rebecca Fitzgerald and Harry De...
Zeynep Pamuk on science courts
May 23, 2022 04:45 - 44 minutes - 66.4 MBCould the implications of science advice, and the policies that follow from it, be decided by a citizen jury following a courtroom battle between scientific adversaries? Dr Zeynep Pamuk thinks so, and in this episode she tells Toby Wardman why. Resources mentioned in this episode Politics and expertise: How to use science in a democratic society: https://press.princeton.edu/books/ebook/9780691218946/politics-and-expertise Arthur Kantrowicz on science courts: https://www.jstor.org/stable/2...
Jakub Bijak and Daniela Vono on science advice in migration policy
May 09, 2022 04:45 - 39 minutes - 59.6 MBSome of our discussions on this podcast can veer towards the abstract and philosophical. Not today! Migration policy is an area where high-minded principles drive headlong into authentic realpolitik — an area where science has lots to offer, but how much of it is actually listened to, never mind implemented, is a whole different question. Two experts on migration policy, Professor Jakub Bijak and Dr Daniela Vono, debate with Toby Wardman the pros and cons of working in such a contentious are...
Bianca Nogrady on abuse of science advisors
April 25, 2022 04:45 - 39 minutes - 59.3 MBWe should be careful what we wish for. The Covid-19 pandemic ushered in a new era of public prominence for science advice, and the emergence of a new breed of 'celebrity' advisor whose face was recognisable from our TVs, newspapers and bedspreads. But in the modern world, public prominence has a dark side too. Science journalist Bianca Nogrady has researched the increasing issue of abuse and threats directed at science advisors. In this episode, she outlines what's going on, what causes it,...
Ortwin Renn on the many roles of science advisors
April 11, 2022 04:45 - 42 minutes - 62.6 MBProfessor Ortwin Renn is one of Europe's leading academic authorities on scientific advice, complexity and risk. In this wide-ranging conversation on the multiple roles played by science advisors, he discusses the limits of science as a source of knowledge, the challenge of complexity and wicked problems, why scoping is so hard, science as a catalyst, tangled values, good and bad faith motivations, and much more besides.
Erin Macdonald on being Star Trek’s science advisor
March 28, 2022 04:46 - 46 minutes - 64.1 MBWhat joint challenges are faced by policy advisors and TV advisors? Why would a committed scientist make the switch from basic research to the entertainment industry? How serious is Star Trek about 'getting the science right'? In this reissue of an episode from 2020, Dr Erin Macdonald discusses these questions with Toby Wardman of SAPEA. We also discuss the nature of gene transfer in tardigrades, whether it’s wise to step into the transporter, and how to solve the Heisenberg uncertainty pri...
Helen Keller on science, policy and the European Court of Human Rights
March 14, 2022 04:45 - 49 minutes - 72.7 MBJust as politicians and policymakers need scientific advice to inform their decisions, so too do judges. But in the adversarial context of a courtroom, science and evidence can be even more hotly contested than in the public policy sphere. And in recent years, campaigners from several European countries have tried to bring the science of climate change before the European Court of Human Rights in Strasbourg, hoping to force national governments into dramatic policy changes. In this episode,...
Diana Ürge-Vorsatz on what makes the IPCC tick
February 28, 2022 05:45 - 54 minutes - 79.1 MBOn the same day this episode went live, the world-renowned IPCC published its comprehensive report on climate change impact and adaptation. Taking time out of a hectic 24-hour calendar of scientific meetings and reviews, Professor Diana Ürge-Vorsatz — one of the coordinating lead authors — sat down a week earlier with Toby Wardman of SAPEA to provide a fascinating insider insight into the workings of IPCC and the secret sauce that keeps the world's best-known scientific advice mechanism firi...
Matthew Flinders on science, political accountability and blame
February 14, 2022 05:45 - 43 minutes - 64 MBCombative debate, accusations and blame are often seen as legitimate tools in the toolbox of partisan political debate. Now, in the new world of high-profile science advisors stepping (or being dragged) into the political limelight, should they be held to the same standards of accountability as their political colleagues? Two years on from the start of the pandemic, an era of public enquiries is beginning, and Professor Matthew Flinders has something to say about the dangers scientists face...
Silvio Funtowicz on post-normal science advice
January 31, 2022 05:45 - 45 minutes - 66.4 MBProfessor Silvio Funtowicz is one of the originators of the concept of post-normal science, which urges us — both scientists and policymakers — to widen the sources of evidence we draw on, the kinds of knowledge we recognise, and the communities who evaluate our success. In this wide-ranging conversation, Professor Funtowicz lays out the history of post-normal science and delves deeply into its implications for the science-policy interface, especially in a world grappling with multiple publ...
Becca Shellock and Mark Dickey-Collas on gaining, losing and repairing trust
January 17, 2022 05:45 - 35 minutes - 52.3 MBThe International Council for the Exploration of the Seas is a century-old science advice mechanism. Throughout its long and storied history, it has gained, lost and repaired the trust of national governments and international institutions on many occasions. In this episode, a social scientist from the Australian National University and the chair of the ICES advisory committee discuss strategies for building and maintaining trust at the science-policy interface — and what goes wrong when sc...
Mario Giampietro and Roger Strand on confronting uncomfortable knowledge
December 13, 2021 05:45 - 56 minutes - 81.8 MBPolicymakers, like the rest of us, construct narratives to understand how the world works and to justify decisions based on that. At their best, these are shaped by scientific evidence. But even the best-informed narratives must by definition leave something out — and when what is left out would challenge or undermine the narrative, this is 'uncomfortable knowledge'. Our guests today, Mario Giampietro and Roger Strand, argue that failure to confront uncomfortable knowledge in a variety of i...