Fifty years ago, a devastating fire raged through Our Lady of Sacred Heart Church, destroying the meeting place of a 112-year-old religious community.

About 100 firefighters finally brought the church fire under control as temperatures hovered around 0 degrees. But the next morning, only smoldering ruins remained. Stone walls had a layer of ice. The only other thing still standing was the 100-foot high bell tower.

Kelly and Christina talk about this fire, its mysterious cause and how the community today seeks to prevent disasters like this one from happening again.

Contact & credits

Episode is edited by Christina Knott. Intro music is "Nobody Calls It San Fran" by Coyote Hearing. Outro music is "The Papergirl" by The Whole Other

Follow us on @SecondLookHistory on Facebook and Instagram, or email us at [email protected] to share feedback or your own tales from history. 

Show your support

To subscribe to the Watertown Daily Times at NNY360, visit nny360.com.

Superfans of Second Look can now show their love for us by ordering a fan sticker at Society6

You can also follow our affiliate link to get a free audio book from Audible.com and try it out for 30 days. Enter our promo code "secondlook" at Audible.com or visit www.audibletrial.com/secondlook.

To learn more

For more information on our show today, visit nny360.com. To read about the fire at Notre Dame inspired plans to preserve local church artifacts during a fire, click here.