Season 14, Time For A Podcast
328 episodes - English - Latest episode: 8 days ago - ★★★★★ - 33 ratingsAn obsessive fan, a fanfiction author, and a first time viewer go through every episode of Supernatural.
Homepage Apple Podcasts Google Podcasts Overcast Castro Pocket Casts RSS feed
Episodes
12.04 - American Nightmare
April 21, 2024 04:00 - 58 minutes - 80.2 MBSam and Dean learn once again that people can be worse than monsters when they discover a girl with powers she can barely control. We like the episode, hate the British Men of Letters, and how everyone has mommy issues. Like everyone. Patreon Bluesky Instagram Tumblr Facebook
12.03 - The Foundry
April 14, 2024 04:00 - 57 minutes - 79.5 MBMary finds a case, Sam and Dean are overprotective, and Cas and Crowley go on their own Lucifer-hunting adventure while Rowena is stuck helping the archangel. We read our first podcast review in over a year, love Mary's haircut, and can't stand the cold open couple. Patreon Bluesky Instagram Tumblr Facebook
12.02 - Mamma Mia
April 07, 2024 04:00 - 1 hour - 87.8 MBSam? Still abducted! Dean and Mary? Still awkward! Cas? Still delivering great lines! Crowley? Still making Rowena's life miserable! We discuss how this episode upset Jess, the Buck-Leming Bingo Card, and how Rowena always looks good no matter what. Patreon Bluesky Instagram Tumblr Facebook
12.01 - Keep Calm and Carry On
March 31, 2024 04:00 - 1 hour - 87 MBMary is back, it's all kinds of complicated, and the British Men of Letters think they know how to break Sam Winchester. Amateurs! We are instantly sent into a nostalgia spiral, talk about how much we already dislike the British Men of Letters, and how wonderful Mary is. Patreon Bluesky Instagram Tumblr Facebook
Watchalong - Love Hurts
March 24, 2024 04:00 - 51 minutes - 71 MBTime for the season 11 watchalong where we get a much-improved episode from the same writing duo from our previous watchalong, but we still have lots of questions for some of the choices (mostly from the awful husband.) Patreon Bluesky Instagram Tumblr Facebook
Watchalong - Halt & Catch Fire
March 17, 2024 04:00 - 46 minutes - 63.7 MBWe get to return to doing a watchalong and go back to season 10 (which we skipped during the WGA and SAG-AFTRA strikes). It's time to rewatch one of the worst episodes in this show's history and we are not kind to it. Patreon Bluesky Instagram Tumblr Facebook
11.23 - Alpha and Omega
March 10, 2024 05:00 - 1 hour - 125 MBAmara has beat Chuck and reality is about to end. Team God is desperate so they decide to turn Dean into a bomb, but he would rather use his words. We read two emails from listeners and get into our fandom histories, discuss how Jess never saw this ending coming, and found ourselves wanting more from Season 11. Patreon Bluesky Instagram Tumblr Facebook
11.22 - We Happy Few
March 03, 2024 05:00 - 1 hour - 96.1 MBGod and Lucifer are reunited and it's time to...start with "I feel" statements? We discuss how Jess's dream is crushed, how Garth is needed for all the things, and the Mega Coven! Want to join us for an episode? Check out Fandom Trumps Hate: https://fandomtrumpshate.dreamwidth.org/ https://fandomtrumpshate.tumblr.com/ Patreon Bluesky Instagram Tumblr Facebook
11.21 - All in the Family
February 25, 2024 05:00 - 1 hour - 103 MBGod is stepping in to help the boys, but Sam and Dean are convinced they'll need to rescue Lucifer in order to have a chance against Amara. Oh and Metatron is a hero now? We discuss the clunky pacing, question whether or not that was really Kevin, and imagine God as a bad roommate. Patreon Bluesky Instagram Tumblr Facebook
11.20 - Don't Call Me Shurley
February 18, 2024 05:00 - 56 minutes - 77.6 MBChuck is back and he's ready to bring his final book. God: An Autobiography. New book means he needs Metatron's help in editing and doesn't seem to care that Amara is going to end the world. Jess can't believe it happened as we discuss Robbie Thompson's fantastic final episode and farewell to the fans. (Apologies for some dog barking in the background.) Patreon Bluesky Instagram Tumblr Facebook
11.19 - The Chitters
February 11, 2024 05:00 - 1 hour - 95.6 MBSam and Dean just can't find Amara because the writers won't let them. But they will get to take a case that one of them will say isn't a case until it's clear it is a case. We've lost track of how many times this happens. We read an email from a listener which prompts us to discuss favorite holiday gifts and then discuss this rather lackluster episode. Patreon Bluesky Instagram Tumblr Facebook
11.18 - Hell's Angel
February 04, 2024 05:00 - 56 minutes - 78.1 MBEveryone is desperate to stop Amara. Crowely, Lucifer, the angels, and even Rowena. (Totally not dead, by the way.) Like a person lost in a desert who finally comes across water, we are so thankful the myth arc has returned even if it is the awkward writing of Buck-Leming. Patreon Bluesky Instagram Tumblr Facebook
11.17 - Red Meat
January 28, 2024 05:00 - 1 hour - 91.8 MBSam and Dean take on ANOTHER random case because they have no leads on Amara and the show thinks it can fool us into thinking Sam or Dean will die. We're missing the myth arc so we give this episode a bit of a hard time as we get distracted by PG's Zoom screen (a lot), relate to Dean yelling at a tree, and wonder about this urgent care. Patreon Bluesky Instagram Tumblr Facebook
11.16 - Safe House
January 21, 2024 05:00 - 52 minutes - 71.5 MBIn a delightful breath of fresh air, Bobby and Rufus return via flashback to deal with a creature Sam and Dean are also hunting in the present. Jess could not have been happier with this episode as we discuss Sam and Dean's mandatory "we have no leads" conversation, Bobby and Rufus's mandatory "we have no leads" conversation, and how Bobby keeps an eye out for construction equipment. Patreon Bluesky Instagram Tumblr Facebook
Season 14, Time for a Hiatus
December 13, 2023 15:21 - 41 seconds - 946 KBWe're taking a break and will be back in mid-January! Patreon Bluesky Instagram Tumblr Facebook
11.15 - Beyond the Mat
December 10, 2023 05:00 - 54 minutes - 74.9 MBSam and Dean pay their respects to an old timer wrestler after his death only to discover there's a demon following the tour. We discuss our random encounters with strangers, Dean's handshake with Gunner, and our first celebrity crushes. Patreon Bluesky Instagram Tumblr Facebook
11.14 - The Vessel
December 03, 2023 05:00 - 1 hour - 87.9 MBSam turns to the history books to find a way to stop Amara and learns about a mysterious object called The Hand of God. In order to find it, Dean has to be sent back in time. We discuss why no one talks about Michael, more of Misha's amazing acting, and have our doubts about the machine translator. Bec Hill's Comedy: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RTH9MKiYvM0&ab_channel=BecHill Patreon Bluesky Instagram Tumblr Facebook
11.13 - Love Hurts
November 26, 2023 05:00 - 57 minutes - 78.5 MBSam and Dean take on yet another monster of the week from the writing duo that has certainly done worse. We celebrate the end of the SAG-AFTRA strike with news about our watchalongs, wonder if a ripped-out heart would hurt or not, discuss the cleverness of the silver pen, and think this is the healthiest conversation Sam and Dean have ever had. Patreon Bluesky Instagram Tumblr Facebook
11.12 - Don't You Forget About Me
November 19, 2023 05:00 - 1 hour - 85.8 MBClaire calls Sam and Dean because Jody and Alex don't believe her when she says there's a case in town. At first it seems like they're right until a body turns up. We discuss how much this show beats up Jody, the benefits of potatoes, and why we like getting older. Patreon Bluesky Instagram Tumblr Facebook
11.11 - Into the Mystic
November 12, 2023 05:00 - 58 minutes - 80.7 MBSam and Dean take a regular case, come across a creature they haven't faced before, make a new hunter friend, and Dean gets the sense that something is off with Cas. We finally get to talk about one of Matt's top five favorite characters, the best parts of Misha's performance, and why the wonderful Dee Wallace was cast. Patreon Twitter Instagram Tumblr Facebook
11.10 - The Devil in the Details
November 05, 2023 04:00 - 1 hour - 87.4 MBSam is trapped with Lucifer, but instead of torture, Lucifer wants to let Sam know how disappointed he is. Jess was not ready for the twists and turns as we discuss the great opening scene, how weird (and great) it is to see a much older Colin Ford, and are excited for the beginning of Casifer! Patreon Twitter Instagram Tumblr Facebook
11.09 - O Brother, Where Art Thou?
October 29, 2023 04:00 - 1 hour - 120 MBOut of options, Sam goes to The Cage to ask for Lucifer's help in fighting The Darkness. Dean ends up finding her and feels all sorts of conflicting feelings. Jess was surprised to learn this episode was written by Buck-Leming as we discuss if their script was trimmed, the weird camera angle used at the beginning, and if Rowena has written fic. Patreon Twitter Instagram Tumblr Facebook
11.08 - Just My Imagination
October 22, 2023 04:00 - 1 hour - 105 MBSam once had an imaginary friend who helped him through some rough times as a child. Turns out that friend was a real creature, there are lots more, and someone is killing them off. Martha comes back for this funny and oh so sweet episode as we discuss Richard Speight Jr's directorial debut, how great all the Zanna are, and who our imaginary friends would be. Patreon Twitter Instagram Tumblr Facebook
11.07 - Plush
October 15, 2023 04:00 - 1 hour - 93 MBDonna needs help with a creepy killer bunny man and later Sam has to face another killer clown. It's pretty great! We discuss scary Easter Bunnies, bad fake tattoos, and how a salt gun shot would really really hurt. Patreon Twitter Instagram Tumblr Facebook
11.06 - Our Little World
October 08, 2023 04:00 - 1 hour - 120 MBSam and Dean go after Amara while Cas goes after Metatron and it's not easier for any of them. We start things off with an email to discuss the afterlife, blame Jess for the death of her recent favorite character, and have issues with certain creepy parts of the episode. Patreon Twitter Instagram Tumblr Facebook
11.05 - Thin Lizzie
October 01, 2023 04:00 - 1 hour - 90.8 MBSam and Dean investigate the Lizzie Borden house to determine if the ghost of Lizzie is taking victims. We discuss facts about possums, a minor continuity error, and invent some new words. Patreon Twitter Instagram Tumblr Facebook
11.04 - Baby
September 24, 2023 04:00 - 1 hour - 102 MBAn episode entirely from the point of view of the Impala. Can't be any good, right? Wrong! It's arguably the show's best episode! Joe rejoins us because he called dibs on this masterpiece long ago as we discuss all the things we love, the details you may not have noticed, and how this episode made us love the show again. Oh and the beginning is not a mistake. Our theme song is left out for the first time because sometimes you just need to let the real music wash over you. Patreon Twi...
11.03 - The Bad Seed
September 17, 2023 04:00 - 1 hour - 110 MBRowena wants to form a coven better than the Grand Coven. Something bigger, badder, more powerful. She wants to form the...MEGA Coven! ...What? We finish off our mailbag (finally), talk about Buck-Leming's nice bounce back, and the best scene in the episode. Patreon Twitter Instagram Tumblr Facebook
11.02 - Form and Void
September 10, 2023 04:00 - 53 minutes - 73.2 MBSam is running out of time to find a cure to the Darkness infection, Dean has to prevent Crowley from taking Amara, and Cas has to just stay alive. Everyone looks like crap at the end. We don't talk about Charlie, point out all the problems with the crib, and wonder where holy oil comes from. Patreon Twitter Instagram Tumblr Facebook
11.01 - Out of the Darkness, Into the Fire
September 03, 2023 04:00 - 1 hour - 94.4 MBThe Darkness is unleashed! She's a being older than time, she's dangerous, and she...is hitting on Dean? Okay, fair. But is Dean into it? Yeah, probably. We are joined by PG's friend Tricky (and winner of our Fandom Trumps Hates auction) to discuss this muddled episode, bad green screens, and the cute little Mark of Cain. Patreon Twitter Instagram Tumblr Facebook
Mailbag 2
August 27, 2023 04:00 - 1 hour - 116 MBWe asked, we begged, and we got a lot of responses for our mailbag! We want to do this as much as possible, so please write to us, ask us any question, tell us any story, and we will read it at our next recording! Patreon Twitter Instagram Tumblr Facebook
10.23 - Brother's Keeper
August 20, 2023 04:00 - 1 hour - 125 MBTime for a finale that makes no sense, was rushed, and leaves us wondering what could have been. We even threw in some rewrites of our own. We support the WGA and SAG/AFTRA, discuss the ups and downs of the episode, the title card, and wonder if Dean would be on another planet or floating in space. Patreon Twitter Instagram Tumblr Facebook
10.22 - The Prisoner
August 13, 2023 04:00 - 1 hour - 104 MBDean angry. Dean smash. We are unimpressed. We discuss Cree Summer, wonder how old Cyrus is, and the Spirit Halloween nurse's costume. Patreon Twitter Instagram Tumblr Facebook
10.21 - Dark Dynasty
August 06, 2023 04:00 - 1 hour - 126 MBCharlie acts nothing like herself, but not because she split herself ito two personalities again. No no. This is because she's being written by Buck-Leming and they thought they had a good idea. They did not. The episode Jess (and everyone) has been dreading. We break it all down. Jeremy Carver unprepared at Comic Con: https://youtu.be/1BYjUTyoEP4?t=2106 Patreon Twitter Instagram Tumblr Facebook
10.20 - Angel Heart
July 30, 2023 04:00 - 1 hour - 129 MBClaire is back and is close to finding out what happened to her mother. When Cas learns what she's up to, he calls in Sam and Dean for backup because he doesn't understand disgruntled teenagers. We are joined by Riley, one of the people who helped spearhead Wayward Daughters, and discuss all the things this episode kicked off and how the fandom came together for something incredible. Patreon Twitter Instagram Tumblr Facebook
10.19 - The Werther Project
July 23, 2023 04:00 - 1 hour - 88.3 MBSam continues to lie to Dean about keeping the Book of the Damned, makes a deal with Rowena, and needs to power down an old Men of Letters vault in order to find another witch's codex to help with the translation. Not too many things to juggle, right? We discuss Matt's paranoia with writing notes, if Garth is immune to the Mark of Cain, and Rowena's excellent outfit. Patreon Twitter Instagram Tumblr Facebook
10.18 - Book of the Damned
July 16, 2023 04:00 - 1 hour - 88.8 MBCharlie returns with the Book of the Damned and an evil family follows her claiming it belongs to them. We discuss the missed opportunity of Charlie in Europe as an episode, Metatron's waffles, and how Robbie tried to warn us all. Patreon Twitter Instagram Tumblr Facebook
10.17 - Inside Man
July 09, 2023 04:00 - 1 hour - 113 MBSam is desperate to find a cure to the Mark of Cain and calls Cas so that the two can break Metatron out of Heaven. In order to do that, they will need the help of the best hunter in the series. We freak out about Bobby, we cry about Bobby, and we love Bobby. Patreon Twitter Instagram Tumblr Facebook
10.16 - Paint It Black
July 02, 2023 04:00 - 1 hour - 95.3 MBDean flirts with a nun, the nun flirts back (we think), and there's a spirit of a person who was pretty much crazy before she died and now is extra crazy. We discuss why Jess can't have nice things, the wrong accents for this location, and Matt yells about a teacup for no reason. Patreon Twitter Instagram Tumblr Facebook
10.15 - The Things They Carried
June 25, 2023 04:01 - 1 hour - 105 MBCole comes back to help with a case in such a way that we had to bring in someone with actual military knowledge in order to understand just how much none of this makes sense. We discuss how hard it was to pay attention to this episode, all the things you need to know about Fayetteville, and we figured out what was really cake this whole time. Patreon Twitter Instagram Tumblr Facebook
10.14 - The Executioner's Song
June 18, 2023 04:00 - 1 hour - 107 MBDesperate to figure out how to resist the Mark, Sam, Dean, Cas, and Crowley work together to trap Cain. When Dean is left alone in a room with him, no one is sure who or what will come back out. We discuss Matt's Mickey Mouse conspiracy, Cain's weird demon powers, and the one part that looks bad. Patreon Twitter Instagram Tumblr Facebook
10.13 - Halt & Catch Fire
June 11, 2023 04:00 - 1 hour - 129 MBSam and Dean have to go deal with a Wi-Fi ghost. Yes really! We discuss every single thing that doesn't work in this episode, want the Cas riverboat gambling episode, and we wonder if this episode was written the night before it was due. Patreon Twitter Instagram Tumblr Facebook
10.12 - About A Boy
June 04, 2023 04:03 - 1 hour - 84.5 MBDean gets hit with magic and himself turned into one of the youths! He can't reach the pedals, likes Taylor Swift, and no longer bears the Mark of Cain. Jess is doing her best to live long enough to record this episode, we love Dylan Everett, and can't but make the Looney Tunes reference (lots of background noise because we recorded during daylight hours). The web comic we talked about: https://consulting-cannibal.tumblr.com/post/70754630875/based-on-this-chat-post-i-just Patreon Tw...
10.11 - There's No Place Like Home
May 28, 2023 04:00 - 1 hour - 108 MBCharlie is back from Oz. Twice! Jess is nervous and we love the episode. But seriously. Jess is very nervous. Matt's New Podcast: https://sites.libsyn.com/469407/GoodMovieBadMovie Patreon Twitter Instagram Tumblr Facebook
10.10 - The Hunter Games
May 21, 2023 04:00 - 1 hour - 86.4 MBSam, Dean, and Cas try to get Metatron to help remove the Mark of Cain, but he says it will cost them. Cas tries to help Claire even though she all she can do is attract the worst kind of people, and Rowena continues to manipulate Crowley (who totally thought he was about to go on a date with Dean). We discuss how we didn't get enough of Guthrie, how easy it is to fool angels, and how excited Crowley was to hang out with Dean again. Patreon Twitter Instagram Tumblr Facebook
10.09 - The Things We Left Behind
May 14, 2023 04:01 - 1 hour - 124 MBCas goes in search of Claire Novak and finds that doing the right thing is complicated. When he brings in Sam and Dean to help, things get worse. Blood bath kind of worse. We are joined by returning guest TheXphial to discuss the terrible group home, Cas's great Jimmy impression, and just how different Dean gets around Cas. Patreon Twitter Instagram Tumblr Facebook
10.08 - Hibbing 911
May 07, 2023 04:16 - 1 hour - 86.2 MBThe team up you didn't know you needed? Jody and Donna!! We discuss how good this episode makes us feel, wonder why someone would investigate strange sounds (again), and we all hate Doug. Patreon Twitter Instagram Tumblr Facebook
10.07 - Girls, Girls, Girls
April 30, 2023 04:00 - 1 hour - 98.1 MBSam and Dean are on the trail of a powerful witch who is attempting to build a new coven and kills a demon along the way. Crowley cannot stand for this and has her taken. Oh and Cole shows back up and something about Hannah kissing Cas. We discuss the return of the redhead, are oh so happen to finally talk about Rowena, and the knife-gun monster. Patreon Twitter Instagram Tumblr Facebook
10.06 - Ask Jeeves
April 23, 2023 04:00 - 1 hour - 120 MBSam and Dean find themselves in a real-life game of clue complete with all the weapons! But they have to hold the idiot ball for the plot to work and we're okay with that because it's quite entertaining. We discuss the Tony Hawk Pro Skater games, a new podcast that Jess recommends, and we have an old-fashioned tangent to start the episode. National Parks After Dark: https://www.npadpodcast.com/ Patreon Twitter Instagram Tumblr Facebook
10.05 - Fan Fiction
April 16, 2023 04:00 - 2 hours - 168 MBIt's the show's 200th episode where Sam and Dean find themselves looking into a case that surrounds a high school play called Supernatural: The Musical (and it's amazing!) Martha is back as we discuss how much we love the episode. Everything about it. Even the deleted scenes. Delete Scenes: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fVVXJSz-wd8&ab_channel=SupernaturalInsider Patreon Twitter Instagram Tumblr Facebook