On The Island - A Podcast Mostly About 'Survivor'
133 episodes - English - Latest episode: about 2 years ago - ★★★★★ - 27 ratingsTaylor Gaines and a rotating cast of co-hosts talk "Survivor," Television, Movies, Podcasts, and the Latest in Pop Culture.
Homepage Apple Podcasts Google Podcasts Overcast Castro Pocket Casts RSS feed
Episodes
‘Survivor’ 42 Finale Breakdown! Get a Grip (Child)
May 28, 2022 13:58 - 1 hour - 43.3 MBTaylor Gaines and Tyler B. Commons convene to build big fires — and to discuss the Season 42 finale of "Survivor." They do some classic bits, including questioning whether viewers can trust the jury, debating why the show feels worse than it used to be even when it's pretty good, comparing the show to sports a bunch, and much, much more. Apple Podcasts Spotify Twitter
‘Survivor’ 42 Finale Preview! A Very Maryanne Christmas
May 20, 2022 12:29 - 50 minutes - 37.6 MBTaylor Gaines and Tyler B. Commons return to break down the rise of a new Season 42 contender in this finale preview episode! They discuss how two players (unintentionally) orchestrated a classic “Survivor” moment, the formation of a stacked jury, what’s going on in Ty’s life (and with his fantasy “Survivor” team), and the entire […]
‘Survivor 42’ “~*Merge*~” Episode! Not A Movie Podcast Either
April 15, 2022 15:44 - 1 hour - 53.1 MBTaylor Gaines and Tyler B. Commons are back to shatter the hour glass and break down everything that’s happened so far in “Survivor” Season 42! They discuss the most likely winners, the lack of a standout power player, the greatest athletic performer in “Survivor” history, the absence of an overarching theme, and much, much more. […]
‘Survivor’ 42 “~*Merge*~” Episode! Not A Movie Podcast Either
April 15, 2022 15:44 - 1 hour - 53.1 MBTaylor Gaines and Tyler B. Commons are back to shatter the hour glass and break down everything that’s happened so far in “Survivor” Season 42! They discuss the most likely winners, the lack of a standout power player, the greatest athletic performer in “Survivor” history, the absence of an overarching theme, and much, much more. […]
‘Survivor 42’ Preview! Travies for a Hobble
March 02, 2022 23:13 - 1 hour - 68.4 MBTaylor Gaines and Tyler B. Commons RETURN from a multi-year slumber to preview a brand-new “Survivor” season. They look back on what they’ve missed, pay their respects to an all-time great, and set up the season the only way they know how: draft style! Many may listen, but only one will prevail. Season 42 debuts […]
‘Survivor’ 42 Preview! Travies for a Hobble
March 02, 2022 23:13 - 1 hour - 68.4 MBTaylor Gaines and Tyler B. Commons RETURN from a multi-year slumber to preview a brand-new “Survivor” season. They look back on what they’ve missed, pay their respects to an all-time great, and set up the season the only way they know how: draft style! Many may listen, but only one will prevail. Season 42 debuts […]
Comedy Joke: This One’s for Tom Brady (w/Annie Scott)
February 15, 2021 22:30 - 1 hour - 56.5 MBSubscribe to Taylor’s new podcast, Comedy Joke, wherever you listen. This episode — with special guest Annie Scott — features the formation of Banana Land, a father with a penchant for metaphor, a grad student trying to solve the big problems and Peyton Manning’s extended family. Christian has a bone to pick with the “Midwest,” […]
Introducing: Comedy Joke
December 28, 2020 21:54 - 1 hour - 53.2 MBThis episode features frat guys attempting improv comedy, a jingoistic car dealership and Scraggles the Zombie Cat. Sophia discusses “Islamic residuals,” Christian talks about buying two cars welded together, and Taylor unveils ‘The Hollywood Development Game’ — which quickly makes him lose his mind. Instagram Twitter
A Finale Episode (w/Michelle Schubert)
May 15, 2020 08:00 - 1 hour - 70.4 MBTaylor Gaines and Tyler B. Commons are joined by their other co-host, Michelle Schubert, to take stock of an all-time "Survivor" season. They talk about Tony's potential GOAT status, Sarah's showcase, Michele's survival, the "Edge" advantage, and so, so much more. Michelle (with two "Ls") also shares some insights into returning home from "Survivor" and rice portions. Stay tuned until the end for an announcement about the future of the podcast. Apple Podcasts Spotify Twitter
The Television Show Formerly Known as ‘Survivor’ (‘Survivor’ S40E13)
May 08, 2020 08:00 - 53 minutes - 46.1 MBTaylor Gaines and Tyler B. Commons prepare for the final battle in "Winners at War," dissecting the strangely anticlimactic penultimate episode, the purpose of fire tokens, what "Survivor" has gained and lost over the years, and much more. They also rank the remaining contestants in their final Power Rankings. Apple Podcasts Spotify Twitter
The End of the Fork (‘Survivor’ S40E12)
May 01, 2020 08:00 - 49 minutes - 41.6 MBTaylor Gaines and Tyler B. Commons return to make sense of a chaotic episode of "Winners at War." They try to figure out how the vote shook out the way it did, what Jeff finds interesting about the show and how badly they want some peanut butter. They also break down each of the seven remaining castaways. Apple Podcasts Spotify
Making Gaines (Family Dreams Come True) (‘Survivor’ S40E11)
April 24, 2020 08:00 - 45 minutes - 36 MBTaylor Gaines returns with a vengeance, bringing his family along for the fight. They break down Tony's controlled chaos and long-term prospects, Sophie's rapid downfall, Jeremy's intuition and what a "quiet day" means on Survivor. Apple Podcasts Spotify Twitter
An Un-Common(s) Family Visit (‘Survivor’ S40E10)
April 17, 2020 08:00 - 38 minutes - 29.2 MBTaylor Gaines cedes the floor to Tyler B. Commons for a very special family visit episode. Ty is joined by his own mother and father to discuss the season to date, the unique loved ones' visit, a wild Tribal Council and much more. Apple Podcasts Spotify Twitter
Is THAT An Idol? (‘Survivor’ S40E9)
April 10, 2020 08:00 - 42 minutes - 35.2 MBTaylor Gaines and Tyler B. Commons try to figure out what's an immunity idol and what's not, breaking down Adam's stunning season-long downfall, Ben's Boston Rob-like turn, Tony's explanation of Tribal Council, Nick's fury, and the game finally breaking open. Apple Podcasts Spotify Twitter
They’re All Earthquakes (‘Survivor’ S40E8)
April 03, 2020 08:00 - 59 minutes - 48 MBTaylor Gaines and Tyler B. Commons are joined by Off Book's Jessica McKenna to talk about the best season of Survivor in history (??) following the latest merge episode. They discuss Tyson's peanut butter cals, Wendell's overconfidence, being cold and wet, earthquakes vs. hurricanes, two-hour episodes, and much more. The Ringer's Guide to Binge-Watching 'Survivor' Apple Podcasts Spotify Twitter
A Blessing and a Curse (‘Survivor’ S40E7)
March 27, 2020 08:00 - 42 minutes - 35.3 MBTaylor Gaines and Tyler B. Commons try to solidify their alliance before the merge. They talk Sandra's white flag, Yul going stag, Rob securing the bag, and much more. Apple Podcasts Spotify Twitter
Queen Slays Queen (‘Survivor’ S40E6)
March 20, 2020 08:00 - 41 minutes - 36.1 MBTaylor Gaines and Tyler B. Commons continue their lifelong practice of social distancing — breaking down the latest Survivor double tribal action. Topics include: Denise's epic move, Sandra's greed, Wendell and Michele's feud, the old-school getting schooled, peanut butter, and more. Stay safe out there, friends. Wash your hands. Apple Podcasts Spotify Twitter
The Show Goes On (‘Survivor’ S40E5)
March 13, 2020 15:50 - 16 minutes - 12.1 MBYou may notice there's no theme music today. Or Taylor P. Gaines. He's on a work trip (IN CANADA). In his stead, Tyler B. Commons takes over for a very special edition of "Zohn the Island." He breaks down the latest Survivor action and the big news about impending Survivor seasons as a result of COVID-19. Stay safe out there, everyone. Apple Podcasts Spotify Twitter Instagram
Fight Hard (‘Survivor’ S40E4)
March 06, 2020 09:00 - 45 minutes - 38.7 MBTaylor Gaines and Tyler B. Commons lift each other up. They cover Ethan's inspiring journey (and Natalie going into Beast Mode), Rob's rebound, Adam's up-and-down journey, and the lines finally being drawn at the red camp. Apple Podcasts Spotify Twitter Instagram
What Heartbreak Looks Like (‘Survivor’ S40E3)
February 28, 2020 09:00 - 43 minutes - 36.5 MBTaylor Gaines tries to get Tyler B. Commons through a tough time. Topics include Ethan's devastating departure, Tony's shark tale, Rob's remarkable hold on power, Adam's big swing, Natalie's puzzle-solving, Jeremy and Michele's team-up, and more. Apple Podcasts Spotify Twitter Instagram
How Is This Guy Still Alive? (‘Survivor’ S40E2)
February 21, 2020 09:00 - 35 minutes - 29.7 MBTaylor Gaines and Tyler B. Commons convene to talk through a second straight episode of tension and intrigue. They marvel at Rob's continued survival, try to understand what everyone else is thinking, talk about tree ladders, and much more. Apple Podcasts Spotify Twitter Instagram
Warp Speed (‘Survivor’ S40E1)
February 14, 2020 09:00 - 56 minutes - 49.8 MBTaylor Gaines and Tyler B. Commons return! They break down the breathtaking two-hour premiere of "Survivor: Winners At War," highlighting each of the 20 castaways as well as some key moments from the episode. They also look forward to a season destined to be full of paranoia and anxiety. Apple Podcasts Spotify Twitter Instagram
Michelle Schubert Returns to the Island for “The Final Lesson” (‘Survivor’ S39E14)
December 20, 2019 09:00 - 1 hour - 61.5 MBTaylor Gaines and Tyler B. Commons are joined by former castaway Michelle Schubert to put an end to this season of "Survivor." They discuss Tommy's surprisingly satisfying win, the new ways to win "Survivor," and, of course, Jeff Probst finally apologizing for the Dan debacle. Twitter Thread About Misbehavior and Misconduct at CBS Link to Press Coverage About New "Survivor" Rules Apple Podcasts Spotify Twitter Instagram
Lost Soles (‘Survivor’ S39E13)
December 13, 2019 09:00 - 46 minutes - 40.4 MBTaylor Gaines and Tyler B. Commons sort through the mess CBS has made for itself following Dan's ejection from "Survivor: Island of the Idols." Apple Podcasts Spotify Twitter Instagram
These Are The Dumbest Moves (‘Survivor’ S39E12)
December 06, 2019 09:00 - 41 minutes - 36.8 MBTaylor Gaines and Tyler B. Commons reunite for the family visit episode to discuss Noura's unbelievable television performances, Karishma's run petering out, and which remaining castaways might be easiest to root for. They also offer up their latest Power Rankings. Apple Podcasts Spotify Twitter Instagram
Taylor’s Dad Returns to the Island (‘Survivor’ S39E11)
November 29, 2019 09:00 - 37 minutes - 31.1 MBTaylor Gaines is joined by his dad, Ken Gaines, to talk through the Turkey Week episode of "Survivor: Island of the Idols." They analyze Karishma's bold play, Lauren's (mostly) great episode, and some of the troubling and contradictory statements about this season's controversies from Jeff Probst. Taylor's dad also unveils his wild new idea for a "Survivor" theme before the pair discusses who will come for the family visit episode and offers their Week 10 Power Rankings. Apple Podcasts ...
Erring and Messy (‘Survivor’ S39E10)
November 22, 2019 09:00 - 53 minutes - 47.9 MBTaylor Gaines and Tyler B. Commons deal with some more aftermath from the merge episode before diving into its effects on the most recent "Survivor" and the game going forward. Apple Podcasts Spotify Twitter Instagram
This Is Not The Way It Should Go (‘Survivor’ S39E8/9)
November 15, 2019 09:00 - 21 minutes - 18.5 MBTyler B. Commons talks through one of the most controversial and unsettling episodes in "Survivor" history. Apple Podcasts Spotify Twitter Instagram
This Is Not The Way It Should Go (‘Survivor’ S39E8)
November 15, 2019 09:00 - 21 minutes - 18.5 MBTyler B. Commons talks through one of the most controversial and unsettling episodes in "Survivor" history. Apple Podcasts Spotify Twitter Instagram
Uncalculated Risk (‘Survivor’ S39E7)
November 08, 2019 09:00 - 45 minutes - 40.8 MBTaylor Gaines and Tyler B. Commons open the floor for conversations surrounding sexism on "Survivor," Kellee's bold Tribal Council strategy, Janet's atypical Island of the Idols visit, and much more. They also unveil their Week 7 Power Rankings. Apple Podcasts Spotify Twitter Instagram
Backbone (‘Survivor’ S39E6)
November 01, 2019 08:00 - 54 minutes - 48.8 MBTaylor Gaines and Tyler B. Commons sit down to talk about the latest episode of "Survivor: Island of the Idols." They discuss Jamal and Jack's dialogue at length before diving into Elaine's potentially game-shifting vote block and all of its implications. They also talk about pillows, power rankings and predictions for huge plot twists that might happen down the road. Apple Podcasts Spotify Twitter Instagram
Unsponsored Content (‘Survivor’ S39E5)
October 25, 2019 08:00 - 47 minutes - 43.2 MBTaylor Gaines and Tyler B. Commons abandon their meals at an average chain restaurant to reconvene over a new "Survivor" episode. They break down the half of the episode that wasn't sponsored, including the tribe swap, Rob & Sandra's absence, Karishma's survival, Detective Dean Kowalski, and Survivor's ill-fated first Canadian. Russell Westbrook Haircut Apple Podcasts Spotify Twitter Instagram
Lie With Me (‘Survivor’ S39E4)
October 18, 2019 08:00 - 33 minutes - 29.8 MBTaylor Gaines and Tyler B. Commons return for another week of 'Survivor' talk. They cover Noura's epic and legendary failure, Chelsea and Dean's "showmance," what "playing Survivor" actually means, when a blindside isn't a blindside, and much more. Apple Podcasts Spotify Twitter Instagram
The Same Island (‘Survivor’ S39E3)
October 12, 2019 08:10 - 44 minutes - 36.7 MBTaylor Gaines and Tyler B. Commons convene IN PERSON to break down the latest episode of "Survivor: Island of the Idols." They talk through the show's uneven storytelling, whether Vince deserved his fate (and whether it was Rob and Sandra's fault!), Karishma's isolation, IoI's inconsequential "lessons," and why the producers refuse to show what's actually happening. Apple Podcasts Spotify Twitter Instagram
Coming Soon!
October 11, 2019 08:00 - 38 seconds - 517 KBA teaser. Apple Podcasts Spotify Twitter Instagram
First Gear Shall Be Last (‘Survivor’ S39E2)
October 04, 2019 08:00 - 43 minutes - 39.3 MBTaylor Gaines and Tyler B. Commons wonder about chiropractors and all matter of things following the second episode of "Survivor: Island of the Idols." They break down the Famous Last Words edit, Noura's fascinating performance so far, Rob and Sandra on Sesame Street, and the near-invisible Lairo Tribe. Plus: Week 2 Power Rankings! Apple Podcasts Spotify Twitter Instagram
Start a Fire (‘Survivor’ S39E1)
September 27, 2019 08:00 - 42 minutes - 36.6 MBTaylor Gaines and Tyler B. Commons aim to be decently dope in reviewing the first episode of "Survivor: Island of the Idols." They talk about the cast living up to expectations, Elaine vs. Ronnie, the first trip to Skull Island, Queen Janet, Dan making people uncomfortable, and much more. Finally, they offer up their Week 1 Power Rankings. Apple Podcasts Spotify Twitter Instagram
State of ‘Survivor’ Season 39 w/Andy Dehnart
September 25, 2019 08:00 - 32 minutes - 26.1 MBTaylor Gaines is joined by reality blurred's Andy Dehnart for their bi-annual State of the Union in advance of a new season of "Survivor." They discuss what the show has in common with pizza, their hopes and dreams for "Island of the Idols," and the point at which change becomes stasis. Andy's Column: "Survivor" is pizza: perfect, malleable, resilient. Will we ever just get pizza again? Cast Photos Apple Podcasts Spotify Twitter Instagram
‘Survivor 39’ Preview: You Listened!
September 23, 2019 08:00 - 1 hour - 68.9 MBTaylor Gaines and Tyler B. Commons wake up from their summer slumber to preview an all-new season of "Survivor"! They speculate on the potentially frightening theme, break down the surprisingly diverse cast, and make Final Three/Winner predictions before the fall premiere. Cast Photos Apple Podcasts Spotify Twitter Instagram
Millionaire White Guy in Jeans (w/ Castaway Michelle Schubert — ‘Survivor: Edge of Extinction’ Finale)
May 17, 2019 08:00 - 1 hour - 50.2 MBTaylor Gaines and Tyler B. Commons are joined by former Survivor Michelle Schubert to make sense of Season 38's disastrous and surreal finale. They talk about the poetic justice served to the producers, the most undeserving winner in "Survivor" history, the terrible Edge twist in its finality, why Devens' success may have ruined the castaways and the show, the gigantic drop-off from one season to the next, and who exactly is to blame. They also talk about burning clothes and barfing in ...
Not a Basketball Podcast (Week 12 ‘Survivor: Edge of Extinction’)
May 10, 2019 08:00 - 42 minutes - 38 MBTaylor Gaines and Tyler B. Commons play pessimistic with some pretzels on the penultimate podcast of "Survivor: Edge of Extinction." They discuss whether Devens deserves credit for his attention-grabbing performances, what the quiet players must do right now, why this week was a breaking point for Edge, who Aurora even was, and whether the returner from Edge has any chance of winning. They also unveil full power rankings of "all" five remaining players. Rate and review the show on Apple...
Taylor’s Mom Returns to the Island (Week 11 ‘Survivor: Edge of Extinction’)
May 03, 2019 08:00 - 48 minutes - 41.2 MBTaylor Gaines is joined by his very own mother, Donna Gaines, for the family visit episode! They debate whether Devens is annoying or charming, dissect why this season has been so chaotic, and study Jeff's awkwardness around the concept of familial love. They also talk about Ron's backfiring Reward win, the continued streak of terrible Reward food, who actually has a chance to win the game, whether the jury needs to chill the hell out, and more. Then, Ty hops on to say some stuff about ...
Castaway Sunday Burquest Returns to the Island (Week 10 ‘Survivor: Edge of Extinction’)
April 26, 2019 08:00 - 50 minutes - 38.4 MBTaylor Gaines and Tyler B. Commons are joined by friend of the podcast and "Survivor: Millennials vs. Gen X" castaway Sunday Burquest to sort out the threats and the goats following Week 10 of Season 38. They get Sunday's thoughts on the season as a whole before talking way too much about Reem, debating whether "Survivor" is just a ladder of chaos now, discussing how small moves can be more important than big ones, determining the truth behind food squabbles, and sorting out whether thing...
Hit the Eject Button (Week 9 ‘Survivor: Edge of Extinction’)
April 19, 2019 08:00 - 50 minutes - 42.9 MBTaylor Gaines and Tyler B. Commons eliminate every potential returning guest for this week's podcast. They cover David's futile efforts to stay alive, the rise of the newbies, Jeff talking about balls, Kelley's immunity idol, THE WARDOG, "Survivor" Season 40, and, of course, basketball analogies. Rate and review the show on Apple Podcasts. Follow @OnTheIslandPod for all the latest updates. Click here for the list of "Survivor" winners eligible for Season 40. Click here for the 'Times ...
Comedian Jessica McKenna Returns to the Island (Week 8 ‘Survivor: Edge of Extinction’)
April 12, 2019 08:00 - 58 minutes - 45.7 MBTaylor Gaines and Tyler B. Commons are joined by the delightful Jessica McKenna from "Off Book" to make sense of Survivor's wild week. They talk Kama chaos, Julia and Gavin's poor damage control, where we're headed with Extinction Island, an unbelievable embrace of silence, and the giant and messy "live" tribal. They also use the Power Rankings to sort out who wound up on top. Stay tuned till the end for a bit of improv starring Jessica McKenna and Taylor Gaines (theme song by Tyler B. Co...
Hashtag Big Movez (Week 7 ‘Survivor: Edge of Extinction’)
April 05, 2019 08:00 - 49 minutes - 44.1 MBTaylor Gaines and Tyler B. Commons return to brag about their brilliant analysis and take some more strong stands. They talk about the latest Extinction Island nonsense, what made the Kamas fall apart, who will climb the "Ladder of Chaos," David and Devens' devastating break-up, Ron and Eric's hilarious overconfidence, the scary and strange immunity challenge, and much more. Stay tuned till the end for this week's Power Rankings. (Spoiler Alert for the television show "Lost," by the way?)...
Castaway Carl Boudreaux Returns to the Island (Week 6 ‘Survivor: Edge of Extinction’)
March 29, 2019 08:00 - 1 hour - 49.9 MBTaylor Gaines and Tyler B. Commons are joined for an EPIC episode by Season 37's Carl Boudreaux ("Survivor: David vs. Goliath") to speak the truth about this week's episode of "Survivor" Season 38. They question the effectiveness of the Edge "twist," debate the smarts of the big Kama vote-out, say goodbye to Wendy and Keith, and much more. They also ask Carl if reward food is soggy and unveil this week's Power Rankings. Rate and review the show on Apple Podcasts. Follow @OnTheIslandPod f...
Running Out of Adjectives (Week 5 ‘Survivor: Edge of Extinction’)
March 22, 2019 08:00 - 1 hour - 52.4 MBTaylor Gaines and Tyler B. Commons push themselves to the edge to discuss this week's double episode of "Survivor" Season 38. They talk about Aubry's awful end, The Wardog's weakness, Extinction Island's entertainment value, Lesu's losing, Wendy's 'what-are-you-doing' gameplay, and much more. They also debate different ways to spell "Lauren" and award this week's Power Rankings! Rate and review the show on Apple Podcasts. Follow @OnTheIslandPod for all the latest updates.
Castaway Davie Rickenbacker Visits the Island (Week 4 ‘Survivor: Edge of Extinction’)
March 15, 2019 08:00 - 1 hour - 48.9 MBTaylor Gaines and Tyler B. Commons are joined by Davie Rickenbacker from "Survivor: David vs. Goliath" to make human ladders and break down the fourth episode of "Survivor" Season 38. They discuss Wendy's baffling gameplay, the show's questionable attempts at representation, and the outlook of the new tribe divisions. Ty also asks Davie a question in the new segment, "Questions from a Six-Year-Old." Stay tuned until the end for a very special edition of Power Rankings! Rate and review th...
We’re Vegetarians Now (Week 3 ‘Survivor: Edge of Extinction’)
March 08, 2019 09:00 - 45 minutes - 35.6 MBTaylor Gaines and Tyler B. Commons unite as Warpups to fight off their feelings from the latest episode of "Survivor" Season 38. They talk about the balance between mystery and gimmickry on Extinction Island, the sudden morality of Big Wendy, the (semi-)departure of White Guy in Jeans, the messy narrative of the season so far, and much more. Rate and review the show on Apple Podcasts. Follow @OnTheIslandPod for all the latest updates.