Rebuilding Democracy (Pt. 2) - Disagreement and Civility

On Opinion

English - September 23, 2020 13:08 - 51 minutes - 47.2 MB - ★★★★★ - 9 ratings
Society & Culture News Politics opinion civil discourse parlia polarization turi munthe debate psychology encyclopedia of opinion conversation democracy Homepage Download Apple Podcasts Google Podcasts Overcast Castro Pocket Casts RSS feed

Previous Episode: Rebuilding Democracy (Pt. 1): Equal Citizenship, with Robert Talisse

Next Episode: Why Bias is Rational, with Kevin Dorst

“Democracy runs on disagreement: it is by means of citizens hashing out their differences that democracy can achieve better political outcomes.”

In Part 2 of their podcast, Turi and Bob Talisse follow on from their discussion of Equal Citizenship (and why polarization strains that ideal), to discuss Disagreement and how we build democratic ‘Civility’ to make sure disagreement is working for, not against, democracy.

Disagreement is central to the democratic aspiration. Not only does it enshrine the right of individuals to participate in the democratic process, but it is epistemically useful - it helps us discover and articulate new ideas. But how can we argue properly when all our instincts push to defeat the other side rather than build with them?

Bob Talisse explains that we're programmed to argue (a good thing) but that we must remind ourselves to do so within the bounds of 'civility'. Not 'civility' in the 19th Century sense of the term, but rather 'Civic Friendship' - anchoring our argument in the idea that we're all building the same civic project together, that our disagreement is precisely what makes our collective experience so much better.

Listen in to understand:

Deep Disagreements: the kind of differences no reasoning or logic will ever succeed in bringing togetherHow (and why) we privilege winning arguments over learning from them.Performance Debating: why we love to argue, and why we’re so bad at differentiating real debate with playing to the gallery.Why politicians play to their bases rather than try to convince the other side.How we've merged the notion of fact and opinion.Civil Discourse: what it means and how we can work to build ‘Civic Friendships’.And whether COVID-19 might just bring us back together as societies…

“The informational environment seems directed at dissolving the distinction between knowing what happened and having a judgment about what happened.”