Model Tuning and Predictivism
MCMP – Philosophy of Science
English - April 18, 2019 23:06 - 40 minutes - 620 MB Video - ★★★★ - 1 ratingPhilosophy Society & Culture philosophy logic science language mathematics hannes leitgeb stephan hartmann mcmp lmu Homepage Download Apple Podcasts Google Podcasts Overcast Castro Pocket Casts RSS feed
Previous Episode: Rational Routines
Mathias Frisch (Maryland) gives a talk at the MCMP Colloquium (26 June, 2014) titled "Model Tuning and Predictivism". Abstract: Many climate scientists maintain that evidence used in tuning or calibrating a climate model cannot be used to evaluate the model. By contrast, the philosophers Katie Steele and Charlotte Werndl have argued, appealing to Bayesian confirmation theory, that tuning is simply an instance of hypothesis testing. In this paper I argue against both views and for a weak predictivism: there are cases, model-tuning among them, in which predictive successes are more highly confirmatory than accommodation. I propose a Bayesian formulation of the predictivist thesis.