The Plastic Ban Unreasonable and Unconstitutional and Government Intrusion in the Legal Profession

We start the episode by discussing the federal government's attempt to ban various plastic items. The ban was met with constitutional challenges from the Responsible Plastic Use Coalition and two provinces, Alberta and Saskatchewan. The federal government tried to classify plastic as 'toxic', a categorization that was deemed unreasonable by the judge due to lack of evidence. Furthermore, the government's jurisdiction to regulate garbage and related matters was questioned, as it falls under provincial jurisdiction. This situation offers an insightful glimpse into the power struggle between federal and provincial governments and the limitations of criminal law power.

The episode then moves on to the government's mounting attempts to gain more control over the legal profession. We spotlight a recent case where the federal government tried to compel lawyers to report their clients' transactions to the tax department. This move raises alarming questions about the independence of the legal profession and the sanctity of client-lawyer confidentiality. The episode highlights the efforts of law societies across the country to push back against such government intrusions.

This attempt to force lawyers to turn information over to the government about their clients is an example of why the BC government's proposal to take further control over their regulation of lawyers as part of a "Single Regulator" system is so problematic. 

The last segment of the episode dives into the intricacies of wills and estates, spotlighting a case where a woman passed away without completing her will. The case underlines the importance of having a will in place and the legal repercussions that follow when one isn't. A related case, where a judge validated a woman's wishes for her estate as expressed in a letter, underscores the importance of intent and reasonable action in such scenarios.

Overall, this episode provides a fascinating journey through the legal world's crossroads with societal issues. With expert insights from Michael Mulligan, it serves as an invaluable guide to understanding some of the most complex and contemporary legal challenges of our time.

From understanding the legal and constitutional implications of a plastic ban to the complexities of estate planning and government intrusion into the legal profession, this episode offers an enlightening deep dive into the labyrinth of the law. Whether you are a law enthusiast, a practicing lawyer, or a curious listener, this episode is sure to broaden your understanding of the intricate dynamics of the legal world.

Follow this link for a transcript of the show and links to the cases discussed.