Unsolved Ohio: Circleville Letters and Cindy Anderson's Disappearance

Horrific Heartland

English - December 14, 2022 01:11 - 50 minutes - 68.9 MB
True Crime Homepage Download Google Podcasts Overcast Castro Pocket Casts RSS feed

Previous Episode: Haunted Places in Iowa

Next Episode: The Lethal Lovers of Michigan: Gwen Graham & Cathy Wood

Ohio has its fair share of unsolved mysteries. This episode takes a look at two of the most notorious. First Aimee talks about the Circleville Letters. An entire town is tormented by sinister letters, but who is sending them? The main target is a bus driver named Mary Gillispie. Her husband died a mysterious death, and she almost lost her own life because of the letters! The second case Aimee talks about is the disappearance of Cindy Anderson. Cindy had been having nightmares about being abducted and killed by an unknown assailant. Sadly Cindy's nightmare came true in August of 1981. What happened to Cindy Anderson? Did she foretell her own death?

Sources:
Onlyinyourstate.com/Ohio
Unsolvedmysteries.fandom.com
Wikipedia.org

Facebook: Horrific Heartland Podcast Discussion Group
Instagram & Tik Tok: horrificheartlandpodcast
[email protected]