Between 2010 and 2017 at least eight men would go missing in and around Toronto’s Gay Village that would end up being a part of this case. Those eight disappearances, and their connection, for whatever reason, would fly under the radar of police who seemed to view most of these as just missing men who probably had reasons to go missing. Even though the community at large was certain that there was a serial killer in their midst, taking victims and making them disappear, police would whole-heartedly disagree. Even though the majority of the men that would eventually be tied to Bruce McArthur had many things in common, including age, ethnicity, background, and marginalized status, police either failed to accept that this was the work of one suspect, or multiple suspects working together, until it was far too late. This week we look at how everything FINALLY came together to investigate, capture and put that serial killer behind bars.


Intro Song: "Recurring Anomaly" by Charles Holme


Sources:"Missing From The Village" by Justin LingNo serial killer in Gay Village, says Toronto police EXCLUSIVE: Survivor of Toronto serial killer Bruce McArthur tells how police 'blew it' when they dismissed him as a 'gay hooker' after attack that fractured his skull - only for the murderer to slaughter eight men years later Bruce McArthur Articles from The Toronto Star Bruce MCArthur pleads guilty to eight counts of First-Degree Murder What Made Serial Killer Bruce McArthur Tick?Bruce McArthur denies assaulting man in previously unreleased 2016 police interview 2010-2017 Toronto Serial Homicides'We have to hold them to it': McArthur assault victim hopeful that change will come to policing Who Is Bruce McArthur and Where is He Now?