About 5 years after Kristin vanished, Onuma was located living in a million dollar seaside resort all alone in the town of Kaneohe, Hawaii. He was evicted from the property once his connection to America's most Wanted was discovered. About a month or so later, a briefcase belonging to Onuma was found hidden in the attic and the briefcase contained articles pertaining to the disappearance of Kristen Modafferi.