323: Designing Social Proof

In this week's episode we dive into the murky waters of designing social proof in social networks. From upvotes to view counts, reputation to badges, there are a wide array of tools and patterns at a designer's disposal to communicate quality and popularity. But these patterns each have their own drawbacks, tradeoffs, and vectors for abuse. We dig into these, and more. Plus, as always, we share our cool finds for the week, this time featuring a Figma plugin and a beautiful indie video game.

Golden Ratio Patrons:

Sisu is looking for a thoughtful and data-savvy designer to help build the next generation of analytics software. You can find out more at sisu.ai. (You might recognize Sisu from our interview with Michie Cao)

Flywheel is a delightfully designed managed WordPress hosting platform, thoughtfully built for busy creatives. Streamline your workflow with their slick platform and sweet set of workflow tools perfectly made for designers! Get started at getflywheel.com/designdetails

Follow-up:

New supporters! Thank you to everyone who has joined our Patreon this week:

Timothy Pui-Fai Li
明勳 李
Meena Balasubramaniam
Darren Soulsby
Sahil Chaturvedi
Will
Ronald Huynh
Kryston Schwarze
Coard Miller
Michael Goliver
Kevin Bennett

Ya'll also tweeted sweet nothings at us:

Paweł Szymankiewicz says "This type of @designdetailsfm episode is my favorite one" about episode 322.
Nathan Lindahl says "Definitely recommend @designdetailsfm. More focused on product/career than brand/creativity… but for sure insightful conversations."
Manny says "Thank you guys for answering my question again. And Jesus Christ, there are so much I need to take note for!!! It's like dark mode episode all over again. In a very good way 😍" after we dug into onboarding design in episode 322.
Adam Carroll says "Really enjoyed this episode" - thanks Adam!
Sahil Chaturvedi says "@designdetailsfm FINALLY I'm a Patreon supporter! Thanks for all the great content and genuinely useful information! Always just feels like I'm chatting with a couple buddies about design" - and we say: Thank you so much for your support!
Friend of the pod, Michael Knepprath says "@designdetailsfm

the tier change feels very good imo - simple and welcoming" - super glad to hear!
And last but not least, Mingshun Li says "Just become a patron of @designdetailsfm! The show was my mentor when I was the only designer at my first two jobs. Great to contribute a little bit to the show!" - thank you for supporting the show, it means a lot!

Additionally, last week Brian was able to share what he's been working on for the past few months: GitHub for mobile! Rafa and Kevin over at Layout also discussed the app on their most recent episode.

Industry talk:

This week we dive into the murky waters of designing for social proof: the inputs, signifiers, and patterns that help people determine what is "popular" online.

Instagram is experimenting with hiding like counts which may have implications for influencer marketing.
Facebook tried to capture more emotional nuance when they added reactions to the like button.
In 2015, Twitter killed favorites in favor of likes.
On our episode with Pablo Stanley, we discussed the potentially harmful impact of having a handful of things you create go viral.
Stack Overflow has a robust reputation system that aims to provide an accurate representation of any given's persons contributions to the community.
Quora uses Credentials to communicate the experiences and achievements of any given writer on the platform.
Basecamp uses a feature called Boosts to help people provide higher fidelity feedback than a like button can offer. Brian misspoke and called this feature "kudos."

One Cool Thing:

Brian shared the Vectary Figma Plugin which helps you apply your designs to 3-dimensional product mockups. Its very cool.
Marshall shared Hollow Knight, a beautiful and outstanding indie game that everyone should play. It's very challenging, but offers a simple onboarding experience which helps people ramp up as they go.

Brian and Marshall got a kick out of watching a reaction to a Hollow Knight speed run world record.

Design Details on the Web:

📻 We are @designdetailsfm

🎙 Brian is @brian_lovin and [email protected]
🎙 Marshall is @marshallbock and [email protected]
🎚@Sarahberus and @Luperdev make us sound smarter than we are

🙌 Support us on Patreon - your support literally makes this show possible. Thank you ❤️
❓ Got a question? Ask it on our Listener Questions Hub, and we'll do our best to answer it on the show :)
⭐️ Enjoying the show? Leave us a review on iTunes

Aloha!