In this episode, Elisha continues with part two in her three part series on the Bain family murders. This week, we dive into the family’s strange background and watch the cracks start to appear. Then, Emily discusses a hometown case from 1996 involving a young woman who disappears after a neighbor witnesses her boyfriend physically attacking her in his front yard in Blanchester, Ohio.


Photos from both cases are up on our social media if you’re a visual person (like we are) and need to see where the crime went down. You can also find them on our website, in the Episode Discovery file.


Stalk us on social: Facebook | Instagram | TikTok | Twitter | YouTube


Special thanks to Fuzz Douglas for our kickass theme music. You can find more of his psychedelic goodness on Soundcloud. 



Source material for the Bain Family Murders Pt. 2 case

Black Hands - Podcast

Privy Council Appeal No 9 0/2006 - David Cullen Bain 

The Association Between Peritraumatic Dissociation and PTSD Symptoms: The Mediating Role of Negative Beliefs About the Self

Court told of Bain mum's 'madness'

House of Horrors - Police video of crime scene 

The Perfect Family

The Devil and Mrs. Bain



Source material for the Carrie Culberson case

Cincinnati Enquirer: Dog bites off nose of murderer Vince Doan

American Justice: S14 E7 - “Cheerleader Mysteriously Vanishes”

Facebook: Find Carrie Culberson

Encyclopedia.com: Vincent Doan Trial: 1997

Information about Carrie’s Memorial

The Disappearance of Carrie Culberson TimeLine

Twitter Mentions