In this episode, Elisha continues her story about how Larry Singleton, Mary Vincent’s attacker, gets released from prison and commits a murder of a woman in Sulphur Springs, Florida in 1997. Then Emily takes us back to Westfield, New Jersey to discuss the case of a family who is tormented by a mysterious, threatening letter writer in 2014.

Photos from both cases are up on our social media if you’re a visual person (like we are) and need to see where the crime went down. You can also find them on our website, in the Episode Discovery file.

Stalk us on social: Facebook | Instagram | TikTok | Twitter | YouTube


Special thanks to Fuzz Douglas for our kickass theme music. You can find more of his psychedelic goodness on Soundcloud. 


Source material for the Roxanne Hayes case

People v. Singleton (1980) - California Court of Appeal

PAROLEE SHIFTED AFTER PROTEST

CRIME AND BANISHMENT PAROLED RAPIST IS WELCOME NOWHERE

Outcast Who Maimed Girl to Be on His Own Soon

Murder in Florida brings collective I-told-you-so

Transcript of Lawrence Singleton vs State of Florida

Newsreal: The Return of Larry Singleton

MUTILATED BY HIM 20 YEARS AGO, WOMAN TESTIFIES AT KILLER'S TRIAL

CALIFORNIA EX-CON GETS DEATH IN MURDER

Lawrence Singleton, despised rapist, dies

A victim, a survivor, an artist


Source material for The Watcher case

The Cut article on the story

Realtor.com article: Why the Upscale Suburb of Westfield, NJ, May Be the Scariest Place to Live in the U.S.

Patch article: Westfield Watcher Letters Revealed

In case you’re intrigued by the Jersey Devil

Buzzfeed Unsolved episode: S5 E1 - The Eerie Case of the Watcher

Twitter Mentions